Renée v. Maria

Courtesy of the fertile mind of Michael Monroe, a tempo canon involving Renée Fleming and Maria Callas’s differently paced interpretations of “O mio babbino caro.”

A tempo canon is a canon in which the same music unfolds in several voices at different speeds. The classic example in Renaissance polyphony is the Agnus Dei 2 of Josquin’s Missa l’homme armé Super voces musicales (1502), in which the lowest voice moves twice as fast as the middle voice and the top voice moves three times as fast:

Tallis Scholars, Gimell 206.

Kyle Gann, in his book The Music of Conlon Nancarrow, sets Josquin’s Mass side by side with Nancarrow’s canonic studies for player piano, written several centuries later. In Study No. 19, the tempos obey the ratio 12/15/20:

Studies for Player Piano, Wergo 6907.

Elliott Carter, György Ligeti, Steve Reich, and Arvo Pärt, among many others, have used related principles in their music. In the Kyrie of Ligeti’s Requiem, the main subject begins with a drop from B-flat to A-natural, but each voice breaks away from the initial note at a different time. An awesome cloud of sound begins to grow:

Jonathan Nott conducting the Berlin Philharmonic and the London Voices, Teldec 88263.

Pärt’s Cantus in Memory of Benjamin Britten consists essentially of descending A-minor scales, with the first violins playing sixteen times faster than the double basses:

Dennis Russell Davies conducting the Stuttgart State Orchestra, ECM 817764.