I recently refreshed my stock of the Paper Mate Sharpwriter #2 mechanical pencil, a beloved companion of my writing and reading life. Within moments, as I jotted comments in the margins of Philipp Lenhard’s excellent new history of the Frankfurt School, I had the sense that something had gone horribly wrong. The lines on the page were thinner and fainter, the action rougher and scratchier. I am not the first to take offense, as the video above attests. I found a set of the discontinued pencils on eBay, but I fear for the future, in this and other respects.