Author: JustinDavidson

  • ƒƒƒƒƒƒƒƒ

    Rousenew2005_2

    By Justin Davidson

    Don’t be fooled by the professorial mien: Christopher Rouse likes his music as loud as any teenage headbanger does. He’s the sort of composer who wouldn’t trust a battalion of trombones to play out enough without some encouragement — half a dozen or more ƒs, say. Judging from Mark Swed’s eloquent review, Rouse’s  cloud-stirring Requiem, which had its premiere in Los Angeles over the weekend, sounds like it doesn’t just honor the dead: it wakes them.

    Rouse descends from a proud lineage of cacophonizers. The first episode of Michael Tilson Thomas’s forthcoming public radio show, "The MTT Files" proposes that the ever-increasing noise factor in music comes from the need to compete with an ever more deafening urban environment. (More about DJ MTT anon.)  Rouse writes for a generation reared on stadium concerts, but he does so in the spirit of the late 19th century. Even when he emerged from the morbid mode that occupied him through the 1980s, he remained one of our loftiest, most passionate and most anachronistically sincere composers. Not for him the finely wrought irony of postmodernism, or its ethnic potpourris. He means what he screams.

    I’m looking forward to the day when Rouse’s monster of a piece finally slouches towards New York.

            Justin Davidson

  • A Time for Thoth

    Thoth_2

    By Justin Davidson

    For most of us, March is a little early in the season for a loincloth, but a bracing spring breeze isn’t enough to deter Thoth – not the Ibis-headed Egyptian god, mind you, but the sandaled and feathered prayformer of his own soloperas. Thoth has been a fixture of Central Park for years,  his celebrity documented in  articles, interviews, and even a documentary that won an Academy Award in 2002. For a while, though, he was in  in exile from his preferred venue, Angel Tunnel near Bethesda Fountain, while it was being restored. Now the tunnel’s open and he’s back, his incantatory chants and droning violin reverberating off the gorgeously restored tile ceiling.

    The music is mesmerizing. In a voice that ranges from a Tibetan monkish
    baritone to a pristine soprano, Thoth (a.k.a. Stephen Kaufman, who lives in
    Jamaica, Queens) sings his  ritual epics, while whirling, fiddling, and accompanying himself on bells wrapped around his
    ankles. Since the libretto is in a language of his own invention, it’s
    hard to know what exactly is going on in “The Herma: The Life and Land
    of Nular-In,” but then the same could be said for “Lucia di
    Lammermoor.” Whatever they mean, those are some funky phonemes.

    Being a technologically adept mystic, Thoth maintains a website (which had been disabled by hackers the last time I checked) and a myspace page, where he chronicles the thrill of his return to Angel Tunnel. “I have noticed that I am having less visions than I was having at Trefoil Arch. I’m not sure I understand why.” (I think he means that’s a good thing.)

            Justin Davidson

  • Lincoln Center on My Mind

    Juilliard_construction
    (Thanks to masck (old skool) for the photo)

    By Justin Davidson

    Thought I: Lincoln Center is Molting

    Remember a few years ago, when the talk was that Lincoln Center’s gaggle of constituent organizations would never stop bickering over the renovation plans, never raise the money, never take the plunge? The travertine dowager, it was said, would keep sinking elegantly into disrepair. But take a look at it now: Juilliard has shed its skin, in preparation for adding a whole new wing, including a glass-walled dance studio facing onto Broadway. It’s more than a little ironic that the dismantling begins with Pietro Belluschi’s Juilliard building, which architecture critics of the 1960s praised as the one true incarnation of modernism in a campus rife with aesthetic compromise. Ada Louis Huxtable, the dean of critics at the time, called it “a marriage of form and function in terms of rational simplicity and bare-boned solutions.” Neither Huxtable nor anybody else, however, has been leading protests or writing novella-length Op-Eds defending the building against depraved acts of renovation. Maybe that’s because generations of Juilliard students have found the building more  a
    marriage of ugliness and unfriendliness in terms of labyrinthine
    confusion.

    Thought II:  Long Way to Go

    As I squirmed through New York City Opera’s  superfluous new production of Rossini’s "La Donna del Lago" (loosely translated as "The Lady who Jumped in a Lake"), I kept imagining the company’s new director-in-waiting Gerard Mortier sitting rigidly in the audience, his Flemish frown getting longer and deeper by the minute. The company is usually better than this, and the lame-duck director Paul Kellogg should at some point get his due as a resourceful executive with good taste and an ear for talented young singers. Still, it’s a long way from lame Rossini to the extravaganzas of vulgarity and bold vision that Mortier is famous for. Will he be able to sweet-talk some extra millions out of City Opera loyalists to support his plans, or will the company only be able to afford a few knockoff shockers?

    Thought III: Mini-Moderne

    Children are the cruelest critics. They need better music, better playing and better seats than adults do before they’ll clap like they mean it, let alone jump to their feet. So I was delighted at the reception that the New York Philharmonic Young People’s Concert of "modern" music on Saturday got from the pre-tween crowd, including my own discriminating 9-year-old. "I liked that," he volunteered, which in today’s praise exchange rate is equivalent to a wild, stomping ovation.  The young conductor James Gaffigan made his debut on that concert; I authorize his publicists to use my son’s endorsement for marketing purposes.

    And get this: the boy’s favorite work was not by Debussy, Bartok, Stravinsky or Copland. It was "Katydid Country," a movement from Mason Bates‘ symphony, "Rusty Air in Carolina." Composed in 2006.  Bates uses field recordings of the noisy bugs – a solo, plus a choir of millions – and turns them into an electronic rhythm section for his high-energy orchestra. (My son also enjoyed Webern’s "Five Movements for String Orchestra," which the orchestra played three times.)  When I pointed to a photo of John Adams in the program (the Philharmonic did a lovely job with his "Tromba Lontana") and bragged that I knew him, my son answered coolly: "How come you don’t know all the other composers, Dad?" There’s your audience of the future.

            Justin Davidson

  • The Dewdrop School

    I’m growing increasingly  irritated with all the high-definition conductors, who make symphonies sound the way football games look on those coveted vast, flat screens. Digital video gives everything that comes before the camera a relentless clarity. Every clump of sod and chiselled blade of Astroturf impresses itself on the  retina. Real life looks  bleary by comparison. In the 1970s, the bleached look and meandering camera of movies like Dog Day Afternoon captured the moist haze of New York City in summertime. The fuzziness evoked the sense that most of what we see as we stumble through our lives looks slightly out of focus, slouching at the edge of consciousness. In the 90s, the cop show Homicide launched the era of the jiggling camera, which likewise suggested that experience was too fast and complex to absorb it all. These days, omniscience is in. No image is too trivial to deserve multi-megapixel resolution. Any banal snapshot of a salivating dog can look epic, if the screen it’s shown on is huge and expensive enough. Architects, too, create big pictures of squint-inducing brilliance. Look out of a high floor of most new office towers and you will see the horizon dramatically framed by expanses of ultra-clear, low-iron glass. Skycrapers offer a skydiver’s-eye view.

    Simon Rattle’s performance of Ravel’s Mother Goose and Strauss’ Ein Heldenleben with the Berlin Philharmonic at Carnegie Hall were similarly full of overweeningly magnified detail. You could make out the highlights on all those all those crystalline tremolos and follow the curve of each dewdrop pizzicato. It seems strange to criticize an orchestra for clarity, both because it is so difficult to achieve and because we have come to accept it as the standard of textual authenticity. According to current orthodoxy, since the composer took the trouble to write all those damned little squiggles into the score (and implied a whole lot more),  the best performance is the one that makes audible as much of the filigree as possible. This is, in different guises, the principle that guides performers as ostensibly distinct as  authentic performance practice gurus, minimalist burblers, and Boulez and his Boulezzini. But, really, what’s so terrible about about letting the edges of a chord bleed a bit, or letting some of those waves of fast fiddle notes gurgle indistinctly? Sometimes some judiciously applied atmospheric murk–what a pianist would call pedal–gets closer to the essential truth.

            –Justin Davidson
                JDavidson8 at nyc.rr.com

  • The Boston/Scottsdale Symphony Orchestra

    The Cleveland Orchestra, which has been leaking dollars considerably faster than they can be replenished, hopes that there’s money to made in seasonal migrations to Miami. This is a tack that the orchestras of other snowbound cities might consider: follow that aging audience we’re always hearing about to places where grey is cool. Or what about moving the franchise completely? Baseball teams do it. Why not find a sponsor eager to import a fancy northeastern brand name to the culturally drought-ridden sunbelt? Houston’s already got a symphony and an opera company, so that ‘s out. No disrespect intended, but who’d keep buying tickets to the Scottsdale Symphony if the BSO moved into town?

    — Justin Davidson

  • Ainadamar redux

    Paupshaw_1 The inaugural New York run of Golijov’s Aindamar is under way, and it’s getting strongly mixed reactions. Russell Platt, writing in my own newspaper, had tart words. Tony Tommasini waxed ambivalent in the Times. Richard Dyer of the Boston Globe found Golijov’s music  "hypnotically beautiful and lustrously orchestrated." Other critics were variously smitten and skeptical.

    I attended the second of three performances and I hate to admit it, but I was disappointed. I’m still mesmerized by the score, and  Alex’s eloquent reaction to the Tanglewood premiere two years ago still rings true. But in Rose Hall, the home of Jazz at Lincoln Center, the piece had a muted, dreamy atmosphere that took me by surprise. Where was the juice? Instead of seducing the audience with its carnal dance, the music sounded distant and sacramental, like a doxology wafting from a church door.

    Kelley O’Connor, the peaty mezo-soprano who sings Federico Garcia Lorca, sounded beautiful when I could hear her, which wasn’t often. (All the singers wore body mikes and there was a problem with hers.) The hard-working rhythm section, rather than kick the interludes into a gallop merely embroidered them. Under Miguel Harth-Bedoya, the Orchestra of St. Luke’s seemed unconvinced and somehow managed to sound too loud and too remote at the same time. A taped harangue of Franco’s, which should have felt murderous, instead resembled one of those indecipherable announcements in a New York subway station.

    The hall’s acoustics and amplification system certainly contributed to the evening’s muffled feel – I haven’t heard another performance there with an ensemble in the pit. Another rehearsal or two might have helped. But the heaviest drag on the opera was Peter Sellars’ staging, which included plenty of Tourette’s syndrome gesticulations, tragic poses of the kind that went out with Sarah Bernhardt, and one unforgivable conceit, an execution that gets replayed over and over as if on a Philip Glassian loop: Shoot, crumple, rise, shoot, crumple rise, shoot. . . Stop!

    The thing is, Ainadamar isn’t really an opera at all; it’s a poetic cantata that will probably have its richest life in the concert hall, where nobody minds when nothing happens, or when a spasm of violence  segues into a meditative tableau. On stage, these eventless lengths felt awkward, and Sellars crammed them full of fussy stage business. (Even the unflappable Dawn Upshaw seemed to be struggling with the job
    of lobbing her lamentations over the waves of orchestration from a
    supine position.) In concert, the eyes could rest and let the ears savor the cerulean and magenta hues of Golijov’s score.

                 –Justin Davidson
                        JDavidson8 at nyc.rr.com

  • Another witness

    About that Mozart-crazed UFO, Tom Ziegler writes to say that he got a closer look, and the disruption emanated not from something spaceship-sized but from a nasty little pocket gizmo belonging to a flustered couple in the Third Tier.

    They tried to shut whatever it was off and when that failed, the man and the woman were passing it back and forth and trying to cover it with their coats.  That may explain why you thought it was moving.  Whatever it was had a flashing orange light and sounded like a motion detector.  In any event, they finally stifled the thing and sat there enduring the stares.  What’s strange is that I kept hearing the sound even though it was shut off.  In some weird way, the overtones of the mass matched the sounds of the device.

    Maybe it’s time to update the no-beeping-electronics speech: "Please silence your cell phones, disable portable air-raid alarms, leave home security systems at home, and chloroform your Dobermans. The hall is perfectly safe."

                        –Justin Davidson

  • Musical Chairs

    Image003

    To hear the Met Orchestra at Carnegie Hall from a perch on the First Tier this Sunday will cost you $155. Now, granted that musicians have to eat, James Levine’s services don’t come cheap and there’s the one-stop subway journey from Lincoln Center to consider. But that’s not the only place your money goes. The real way to get to Carnegie Hall in style is to get a job there moving chairs and music stands around the stage.  IRS Form 990 (a non-profit organization’s tax return), which Carnegie filed for the fiscal year ending in June of 2004, is available here. It lists the five highest-paid members of the staff. The late, much missed Robert Harth, who swung from the rigging to scuttle a disastrous merger with the New York Philharmonic topped the list, earning $604,418, plus a benefits package of $141,590. After that, there’s not an executive in sight. Nos. 2,3,4 and 5 on the list are all stagehands, who made between $300,000 and $384,000. And for that kind of change, you don’t get to keep reconfiguring supposedly supple Zankel Hall, which in theory has three different incarnations but has hardly ever budged out of its starting end-stage mode. The payroll situation is similar at Lincoln Center, where the stagehands are comparatively penurious, but still crowd the top earners list. The crew’s biggest moneymaker put in 40-hour weeks and made $216,388 – almost $20,000 more than Nigel Redden, the director of Lincoln Center Festival. The New York Philharmonic uses Lincoln Center’s stagehands, too, which explains why the orchestra managed to keep the biggest salaries flowing towards its players – so long as you don’t count executive director Zarin Mehta (roughly on a par with Robert Harth) and one well-remunerated independent contractor by the name of Lorin Maazel ($1.9 million). It’s enough to make a fiddler wonder whether it wouldn’t make  a more luxurious life in music to stop scraping strings and start moving chairs instead.

                –Justin Davidson

  • Milosz update

    It turns out that "Encounter," the Czeslaw Milosz poem currently on my family blackboard and the subject of an earlier post, is No. 3 in a set of eleven in John Harbison’s "Milosz Songs," soon to have their world premiere. Dawn Upshaw sings (not in Polish, alasz). Robert Spano conducts. Steven Stucky explains. What could be bad ? Never mind, don’t answer that.

                –Justin Davidson
                    JDavidson8 at nyc.rr.com